Minutes
Full council, 9 May 2024: a named vote between a motion and an amendment, lost.
For the motion 41, For the amendment 9, Abstained 0.
Party in overall control of the council on the date: No overall control. Each councillor's party is the one the council recorded for them at the time.
For the motion (41)
- Danny Aston (Scottish National Party)
- Denis Dixon (Scottish National Party)
- Euan Hyslop (Scottish National Party)
- Finlay McFarlane (Scottish National Party)
- Fiona Glasgow (Scottish National Party)
- Kate Campbell (Scottish National Party)
- Lesley Macinnes (Scottish National Party)
- Marco Biagi (Scottish National Party)
- Martha Mattos Coelho (Scottish National Party)
- Neil Gardiner (Scottish National Party)
- Norman Work (Scottish National Party)
- Simita Kumar (Scottish National Party)
- Stuart Dobbin (Scottish National Party)
- Vicky Nicolson (Scottish National Party)
- Cammy Day (Labour)
- James Dalgleish (Labour)
- Jane Meagher (Labour)
- Joan Griffiths (Labour)
- Katrina Faccenda (Labour)
- Lezley Marion Cameron (Labour)
- Mandy Watt (Labour)
- Margaret Arma Graham (Labour)
- Scott Arthur (Labour)
- Stephen Jenkinson (Labour)
- Tim Pogson (Labour)
- Val Walker (Labour)
- Alan Beal (Liberal Democrats)
- Edward Thornley (Liberal Democrats)
- Euan Davidson (Liberal Democrats)
- Fiona Bennett (Liberal Democrats)
- Hal Osler (Liberal Democrats)
- Jack Caldwell (Liberal Democrats)
- Kevin Lang (Liberal Democrats)
- Lewis Younie (Liberal Democrats)
- Louise Young (Liberal Democrats)
- Neil Ross (Liberal Democrats)
- Pauline Flannery (Liberal Democrats)
- Sanne Dijkstra-Downie (Liberal Democrats)
- Lord Provost (not matched to a member)
- McNeese-Meechan (not matched to a member)
- Nols-McVey (not matched to a member)
For the amendment (9)
- Christopher Cowdy (Conservative)
- Graeme Bruce (Conservative)
- Iain Whyte (Conservative)
- Jason Rust (Conservative)
- Joanna Mowat (Conservative)
- Marie-Clair Munro (Conservative)
- Max Mitchell (Conservative)
- Phil Doggart (Conservative)
- Tim Jones (Conservative)
From the minutes
e for no action was lost, a second vote was then taken between the Motion by Councillor Watt and Amendment 1 by Councillor Bruce. Second Vote The voting was as follows: For the Motion For Amendment 1 Abstentions - - - 41 votes 8 votes 11 (For the Motion: Councillors Lord Provost, Councillors Arthur, Aston, Beal, Bennett, Biagi, Caldwell, Lezley Marion Cameron, Campbell, Dalgleish, Davidson, Day, Dijkstra-Downie, Dixon, Dobbin, Faccenda, Flannery, Gardiner, Glasgow, Graham, Griffiths, Hyslop, Jenkinson, Kumar, Lang, Macinnes, Mattos Coelho, McFarlane, McNeese-Meechan, Meagher, Nicolson, Nols-McVey, Osler, Pogson, Ross, Thornley, Walker, Watt, Work, Young and Younie. For Amendment 1: Councillors Bruce, Cowdy, Doggart, Jones, Mitchell, Mowat, Munro, Rust and Whyte. Abstentions: Councillors Bandel, Booth, Burgess, Heap, McKenzie, Miller, Mumford, O'Neill, Parker, Rae and Staniforth.) The City of Edinburgh Council
The item in the council's own minutes. Names are matched to the councillors listed at the meeting. The names of people who aren't councillors are removed.