Minutes
Full council, 15 December 2022: a named vote between a motion and an amendment.
For the motion 23, For the amendment 38, Abstained 0.
Party in overall control of the council on the date: No overall control. Each councillor's party is the one the council recorded for them at the time.
For the motion (23)
- Cammy Day (Labour)
- James Dalgleish (Labour)
- Jane Meagher (Labour)
- Joan Griffiths (Labour)
- Katrina Faccenda (Labour)
- Lezley Marion Cameron (Labour)
- Mandy Watt (Labour)
- Margaret Arma Graham (Labour)
- Ross McKenzie (Labour)
- Scott Arthur (Labour)
- Stephen Jenkinson (Labour)
- Tim Pogson (Labour)
- Val Walker (Labour)
- Alex Staniforth (Green)
- Alys Mumford (Green)
- Ben Parker (Green)
- Chas Booth (Green)
- Claire Miller (Green)
- Dan Heap (Green)
- Jule Bandel (Green)
- Kayleigh Kinross-O'Neill (Green)
- Steve Burgess (Green)
- Susan Rae (Green)
For the amendment (38)
- Adam Nols-McVey (Scottish National Party)
- Catherine Fullerton (Scottish National Party)
- Danny Aston (Scottish National Party)
- David Key (Scottish National Party)
- Denis Dixon (Scottish National Party)
- Euan Hyslop (Scottish National Party)
- Finlay McFarlane (Scottish National Party)
- Fiona Glasgow (Scottish National Party)
- Lesley Macinnes (Scottish National Party)
- Marco Biagi (Scottish National Party)
- Martha Mattos Coelho (Scottish National Party)
- Neil Gardiner (Scottish National Party)
- Norman Work (Scottish National Party)
- Simita Kumar (Scottish National Party)
- Stuart Dobbin (Scottish National Party)
- Vicky Nicolson (Scottish National Party)
- Alan Beal (Liberal Democrats)
- Edward Thornley (Liberal Democrats)
- Euan Davidson (Liberal Democrats)
- Hal Osler (Liberal Democrats)
- Jack Caldwell (Liberal Democrats)
- Kevin Lang (Liberal Democrats)
- Lewis Younie (Liberal Democrats)
- Neil Ross (Liberal Democrats)
- Neil Ross (Liberal Democrats)
- Pauline Flannery (Liberal Democrats)
- Sanne Dijkstra-Downie (Liberal Democrats)
- Christopher Cowdy (Conservative)
- Graeme Bruce (Conservative)
- Iain Whyte (Conservative)
- Jason Rust (Conservative)
- Joanna Mowat (Conservative)
- Max Mitchell (Conservative)
- Phil Doggart (Conservative)
- Tim Jones (Conservative)
- Campbell (not matched to a member)
- McNeese-Meechan (not matched to a member)
- Young (not matched to a member)
From the minutes
addendum to the Composite Amendment. Voting Vote 1 The voting was as follows: For the Motion (as adjusted) For Amendment 1 For the Composite Amendment (as adjusted) - - - 23 votes 19 votes 21 votes (For the Motion (as adjusted): Councillors Arthur, Bandel, Booth, Burgess, Cameron, Dalgleish, Day, Faccenda, Graham, Griffiths, Heap, Jenkinson, McKenzie, Meagher, Miller, Mumford, O'Neill, Parker, Pogson, Rae, Staniforth, Walker and Watt. For Amendment 1: Councillors Aston, Biagi, Campbell, Dixon, Dobbin, Fullerton, Gardiner, Glasgow, Hyslop, Key, Kumar, Macinnes, Mattos Coelho, McFarlane, McNeese-Meechan, McVey, Nicolson, Frank Ross and Work. The City of Edinburgh Council – 15 December 2022 Page 42 of 108 For the Composite Amendment (as adjusted): Lord Provost, Councillors Beal, Bruce, Caldwell, Cowdy, Davidson, Dijkstra-Downie, Doggart, Flannery, Jones, Lang, Mitchell, Mowat, Osler, Neil Ross, Rust, Thornley, Whyte, Young and Younie.) There being no overall majority, Amendment 1 fell and a second vote was taken between the Motion (as adjusted) and the Composite Amendment (as adjusted). Vote 2 The voting was as follows: For the Motion (as adjusted) For the Composite Amendment (as adjusted) Abstentions - - - 23 votes 21 votes 19 (
The item in the council's own minutes. Names are matched to the councillors listed at the meeting. The names of people who aren't councillors are removed.