Minutes
Full council, 21 November 2019: a named vote between a motion and an amendment.
For the motion 33, For the amendment 25, Abstained 0.
Party in overall control of the council on the date: No overall control. Each councillor's party is the one the council recorded for them at the time.
For the motion (33)
- Andrew Johnston (Conservative)
- Callum Laidlaw (Conservative)
- Cameron Rose (Conservative)
- Graeme Bruce (Conservative)
- Graham Hutchison (Conservative)
- Iain Whyte (Conservative)
- Jason Rust (Conservative)
- Jim Campbell (Conservative)
- Joanna Mowat (Conservative)
- John McLellan (Conservative)
- Mark Brown (Conservative)
- Max Mitchell (Conservative)
- Nick Cook (Conservative)
- Phil Doggart (Conservative)
- Scott Douglas (Conservative)
- Stephanie Smith (Conservative)
- Susan Webber (Conservative)
- Alex Staniforth (Green)
- Chas Booth (Green)
- Claire Miller (Green)
- Gavin Corbett (Green)
- Mary Campbell (Green)
- Melanie Main (Green)
- Steve Burgess (Green)
- Susan Rae (Green)
- Gillian Gloyer (Liberal Democrats)
- Hal Osler (Liberal Democrats)
- Kevin Lang (Liberal Democrats)
- Neil Ross (Liberal Democrats)
- Robert Aldridge (Liberal Democrats)
- Claire Bridgman (Independent)
- Gavin Barrie (Independent)
- Lewis Ritchie (Independent)
For the amendment (25)
- Adam Nols-McVey (Scottish National Party)
- Amy McNeese-Mechan (Scottish National Party)
- Catherine Fullerton (Scottish National Party)
- Denis Dixon (Scottish National Party)
- Derek Howie (Scottish National Party)
- Eleanor Bird (Scottish National Party)
- George Gordon (Scottish National Party)
- Ian Campbell (Scottish National Party)
- Kate Campbell (Scottish National Party)
- Lesley Macinnes (Scottish National Party)
- Neil Gardiner (Scottish National Party)
- Norman Work (Scottish National Party)
- Rob Munn (Scottish National Party)
- Cammy Day (Labour)
- Gordon Munro (Labour)
- Ian Perry (Labour)
- Joan Griffiths (Labour)
- Karen Doran (Labour)
- Lezley Marion Cameron (Labour)
- Mandy Watt (Labour)
- Maureen Child (Labour)
- Ricky Henderson (Labour)
- Scott Arthur (Labour)
- Ashley Graczyk (Independent)
- Wilson (not matched to a member)
From the minutes
il, covering the points raised as a matter of course. - moved by Councillor McVey, seconded by Councillor Day Voting The voting was as follows: For the motion For the amendment - - 33 votes 25 votes (For the motion: Councillors Aldridge, Barrie, Bridgman, Booth, Brown, Bruce, Burgess, Jim Campbell, Mary Campbell, Cook, Corbett, Doggart, Douglas, Gloyer, Hutchison, Johnston, Laidlaw, Lang, McLellan, Main, Miller, Mitchell, Mowat, Osler, Rae, Ritchie, Rose, Neil Ross, Rust, Smith, Staniforth, Webber and Whyte. For the amendment: Depute Convener Griffiths, Councillors Arthur, Bird, Cameron, Ian Campbell, Kate Campbell, Child, Day, Dixon, Doran, Fullerton, Gardiner, Gordon, Graczyk, Henderson, Howie, Macinnes, McNeese-Mechan, McVey, Munn, Munro, Perry, Watt, Wilson and Work.) Decision To approve the adjusted motion by Councillor Lang. The City of Edinburgh Council – 21 November 2019 Page 33 of 81 Appendix 1 (As referred to in Act of Council No 3 of 21 November 2019) QUESTION NO 1 By Councillor Osler for answer by the Convener of the Planning Committee at a meeting of the Council on 21 November 2019 With regards to the recent (temporary) development of the Christmas market in East Princes Street Gardens Question (1
The item in the council's own minutes. Names are matched to the councillors listed at the meeting. The names of people who aren't councillors are removed.