Review of Proportionality
Full council, 15 October 2024: a named vote, lost.
For 4, Against 32, Abstained 1.
Party in overall control of the council on the date: Liberal Democrats. Each councillor's party is the one the council recorded for them at the time.
For (4)
- James Giles (Kingston Independent Residents Group)
- Yvonne Tracey (Kingston Independent Residents Group)
- Jamal Chohan (Ind OP)
- Kamala Kugan (not matched to a member)
Against (32)
- Afy Afilaka (Liberal Democrats)
- Alison Holt (Liberal Democrats)
- Andreas Kirsch (Liberal Democrats)
- Andrew Bolton (Liberal Democrats)
- Andrew Sillett (Liberal Democrats)
- Andrew Wooldridge (Liberal Democrats)
- Diane White (Liberal Democrats)
- Elizabeth Park (Liberal Democrats)
- Emily Davey (Liberal Democrats)
- Farshid Sadr-Hashemi (Liberal Democrats)
- Helen Grocott (Liberal Democrats)
- Ian Manders (Liberal Democrats)
- Jackie Davies (Liberal Democrats)
- John Sweeney (Liberal Democrats)
- Lesley Heap (Liberal Democrats)
- Lorraine Dunstone (Liberal Democrats)
- Mariana Goncalves (Liberal Democrats)
- Mark Durrant (Liberal Democrats)
- Mike Massimi (Liberal Democrats)
- Noel Hadjimichael (Liberal Democrats)
- Patrick Hall (Liberal Democrats)
- Peter Herlinger (Liberal Democrats)
- Robert Dongsung Kim (Liberal Democrats)
- Roger Hayes (Liberal Democrats)
- Sabah Hamed (Liberal Democrats)
- Sharukh Mirza (Liberal Democrats)
- Sue Ansari (Liberal Democrats)
- Susan Skipwith (Liberal Democrats)
- Thay Thayalan (Liberal Democrats)
- Tom Reeve (Liberal Democrats)
- Yogan Yoganathan (Liberal Democrats)
- Rowena Bass (Conservative)
Abstained (1)
- Liz Green (Liberal Democrats)
From the minutes
disapplied, a vote was taken and the amendment was lost. Councillors James Giles, Yvonne Tracey, Jamal Chohan and Kamala Kugan requested a recorded vote be taken, under Procedure Rule 12 (1). Voting: For: Councillors Jamal Chohan, James Giles, Kamala Kugan and Yvonne Tracey. (4) Against: Councillors Afy Afilaka, Sue Ansari, Rowena Bass, Lorraine Dunstone, Andrew Bolton, Emily Davey, Jackie Davies, Mark Durrant, Mariana Goncalves, Helen Grocott, Noel Hadjimichael, Patrick Hall, Sabah Hamed, Roger Hayes, Lesley Heap, Peter Herlinger, Alison Holt, Robert Dongsung Kim, Andreas Kirsch, Ian Manders, Mike Massimi, Sharukh Mirza, Elizabeth Park, Tom Reeve, Farshid Sadr-Hashemi, Andrew Sillett, Susan Skipwith, John Sweeney, Thay Thayalan, Diane White, Andrew Wooldridge and Yogan Yoganathan. (32) Abstentions: Councillor Liz Green. (1) Following further debate a vote was then taken on the original motion. Councillors James Giles, Yvonne Tracey, Jamal Chohan and Kamala Kugan req
The item in the council's own minutes. Names are matched to the councillors listed at the meeting. The names of people who aren't councillors are removed.