Opposition Group Motion for Debate
Full council, 10 December 2024: a named vote, lost.
For 10, Against 52, Abstained 1.
Party in overall control of the council on the date: Labour. Each councillor's party is the one the council recorded for them at the time.
For (10)
- Athena Zissimos (Liberal Democrats)
- Connie Hersch (Liberal Democrats)
- Gary Busuttil (Liberal Democrats)
- Gary Malcolm (Liberal Democrats)
- Jon Ball (Liberal Democrats)
- Jonathan Oxley (Liberal Democrats)
- Anthony Young (Conservative)
- Fabio Conti (Conservative)
- Julian Gallant (Conservative)
- Mrs Seema Kumar (Conservative)
Against (52)
- Amarjit Jammu (Labour)
- Anthony Kelly (Labour)
- Bassam Mahfouz (Labour)
- Ben Wesson (Labour)
- Binda Rai (Labour)
- Blerina Hashani (Labour)
- Charan Sharma (Labour)
- Claire Tighe (Labour)
- Daniel Crawford (Labour)
- Dee Martin (Labour)
- Dominic Moffitt (Labour)
- Faduma Mohamed (Labour)
- Gareth Shaw (Labour)
- Ghulam Murtaza (Labour)
- Grace Quansah (Labour)
- Harbhajan Kaur Dheer (Labour)
- Hitesh Tailor (Labour)
- Ian Kingston (Labour)
- Ilayda Nijhar (Labour)
- Jasbir Anand (Labour)
- John Martin (Labour)
- Kamaldeep Sahota (Labour)
- Kamaljit Dhindsa (Labour)
- Kamaljit Kaur Nagpal (Labour)
- Kanwal Kaur Bains (Labour)
- Kate Crawford (Labour)
- Katie Douglas (Labour)
- Kim Kaur Nagpal (Labour)
- Lauren Wall (Labour)
- Louise Brett (Labour)
- Miriam Rice (Labour)
- Mohinder Midha (Labour)
- Monica Hamidi (Labour)
- Muhammad Iqbal (Labour)
- Paul Driscoll (Labour)
- Peter Mason (Labour)
- Polly Knewstub (Labour)
- Praveen Anand (Labour)
- Ray Wall (Labour)
- Rima Baaklini (Labour)
- Sanjai Kohli (Labour)
- Sarfraz Khan (Labour)
- Shahbaz Ahmed (Labour)
- Shital Manro (Labour)
- Stephen Donnelly (Labour)
- Surinder Kaur Jassal (Labour)
- Swaran Padda (Labour)
- Tarept Sidhu (Labour)
- Tariq Mahmood (Labour)
- Varlene Alexander (Labour)
- Yoel Gordon (Labour)
- Dheer (not matched to a member)
Abstained (1)
- Yvonne Johnson (Labour)
From the minutes
ouncillor Hersch moved and Councillor Oxley seconded an amendment to the motion. A vote was taken and the amendment FELL. A recorded vote was held on the original motion and members voted as follows: For: Councillors Ball, Busuttil, Hersch, Malcolm, Oxley, Zissimos, Kumar, Conti, Gallant and Young. Against: Councillors Shaw, S Ahmed, Alexander, J Anand, P Anand, Baaklini, Bains, Brett, D Crawford, K Crawford, Kaur Dheer, Dheer, Dhindsa, Donnelly, Douglas, Driscoll, Gordon, Hamidi, Hashani, Iqbal, Jammu, Jassal, Kelly, Khan, Kingston, Knewstub, Kohli, Mahfouz, Mahmood, Manro, D Martin, J Martin, Mason, Midha, Moffitt, Mohamed, Murtaza, Kim Kaur Nagpal, Kamaljit Kaur Nagpal, Nijhar, Padda, Quansah, Rai, Rice, Sahota, Sharma, Sidhu, Tailor, Tighe, L Wall, R Wall, Wesson. Abstentions: Councillor Johnson The motion therefore FELL.
The item in the council's own minutes. Names are matched to the councillors listed at the meeting. The names of people who aren't councillors are removed.