Petition - Melvin Hall
Full council, 15 July 2024: a named vote on the amendment, lost.
For 16, Against 27, Abstained 6.
Party in overall control of the council on the date: Conservative. Each councillor's party is the one the council recorded for them at the time.
For (16)
- Alisa Igoe (Labour)
- Chris Price (Labour)
- Jessica Arnold (Labour)
- Josh King (Labour)
- Kathy Bance MBE (Labour)
- Kevin Kennedy-Brooks (Labour)
- Rebecca Wiffen (Labour)
- Ruth McGregor (Labour)
- Ryan Thomson (Labour)
- Simon Jeal (Labour)
- Tony McPartlan (Labour)
- Chloe-Jane Ross (Liberal Democrats)
- Graeme Casey (Liberal Democrats)
- Julie Ireland (Liberal Democrats)
- Sam Webber (Liberal Democrats)
- Will Connolly (Liberal Democrats)
Against (27)
- Adam Jude Grant (Conservative)
- Alexa Michael (Conservative)
- Angela Page (Conservative)
- Charles Joel (Conservative)
- Christine Harris (Conservative)
- Colin Hitchins (Conservative)
- Colin Smith (Conservative)
- Diane Smith (Conservative)
- Felicity Bainbridge (Conservative)
- Gemma Turrell (Conservative)
- Hannah Gray (Conservative)
- Harry Stranger (Conservative)
- Kate Lymer (Conservative)
- Mark Brock (Conservative)
- Michael Tickner (Conservative)
- Pauline Tunnicliffe (Conservative)
- Peter Dean (Conservative)
- Shaun Slator (Conservative)
- Simon Fawthrop (Conservative)
- Thomas Turrell (Conservative)
- Tony Owen (Conservative)
- Will Rowlands (Conservative)
- Christopher Marlow (Reform UK)
- Kira Gabbert (Reform UK)
- Jonathan Laidlaw (Independent)
- David Cartwright (not matched to a member)
- Dr Sunil Gupta (not matched to a member)
Abstained (6)
- David Jefferys (Conservative)
- Jonathan Andrews (Conservative)
- Mark Smith (not matched to a member)
- Melanie Stevens (not matched to a member)
- Mike Jack (not matched to a member)
- Sophie Dunbar (not matched to a member)
From the minutes
e held. (3) Act as a responsible landlord to work with the Melvin Hall Community Group to develop a sustainable business plan to ensure the future of Melvin Hall as a Community Centre.” The following Members voted for the amendment – Cllrs Jessica Arnold, Kathy Bance, Graeme Casey, Will Connolly, Alisa Igoe, Julie Ireland, Simon Jeal, Kevin Kennedy-Brooks, Josh King, Ruth McGregor, Tony McPartlan, Chris Price, Chloe-Jane Ross, Ryan Thomson, Sam Webber and Rebecca Wiffen (16) The following Members voted against the amendment – Cllrs Felicity Bainbridge, Mark Brock, David Cartwright, Peter Dean, Simon Fawthrop, Kira Gabbert, Adam Grant, Hannah Gray, Dr Sunil Gupta, Christine Harris, Colin Hitchins, Charles Joel, Jonathan Laidlaw, Kate Lymer, Christopher Marlow, Alexa Michael, Tony Owen, Angela Page, Will Rowlands, Shaun Slator, Colin Smith, Diane Smith, Harry Stranger, Michael Tickner, Pauline Tunnicliffe, Gemma Turrell and Thomas Turrell (27) The following Members abstained – Cllrs Jonathan Andrews, Sophie Dunbar, Mike Jack, Dr David Jefferys, Mark Smith and Melanie Stevens (6) The amendment was LOST. As proposed by Cllr Christopher Marlow and seconded by Cllr Colin Smith, the following motion was put to the vote and CAR
The item in the council's own minutes. Names are matched to the councillors listed at the meeting. The names of people who aren't councillors are removed.