Notice of Motion - Change from Cabinet to Committee Structure
Full council, 26 September 2019: a named vote on the motion, lost.
For 10, Against 42, Abstained 0.
Party in overall control of the council on the date: Labour. Each councillor's party is the one the council recorded for them at the time.
For (10)
- David Greenhough (Liberal Democrats)
- Hannah Kitching (Liberal Democrats)
- Peter Fielding (Liberal Democrats)
- Steve Hunt (Liberal Democrats)
- Andrew Gillis (Barnsley Independent Group)
- Gill Carr (Barnsley Independent Group)
- Phillip Birkinshaw (Barnsley Independent Group)
- Trevor Smith (D&V)
- Victoria Felton (D&V)
- Jake Lodge (Independent)
Against (42)
- Alice Cave (Labour)
- Anita Cherryholme (Labour)
- Brenda Eastwood (Labour)
- Caroline Makinson (Labour)
- Charlie Wraith MBE (Labour)
- Chris Lamb (Labour)
- Clive Pickering (Labour)
- Dave Leech (Labour)
- Dorothy Higginbottom (Labour)
- Harry Spence (Labour)
- Janine Bowler (Labour)
- Jeff Ennis OBE (Labour)
- Jenny Platts (Labour)
- Jo Newing (Labour)
- Joanne Murray (Labour)
- Joe Hayward (Labour)
- Kevin Williams (Labour)
- Margaret Bruff (Labour)
- Mick Stowe (Labour)
- Neil Wright (Labour)
- Nicola Sumner (Labour)
- Pauline Markham (Labour)
- Pauline McCarthy (Labour)
- Phillip Lofts (Labour)
- Robert Frost (Labour)
- Robin Franklin (Labour)
- Sarah Tattersall (Labour)
- Sharon Howard (Labour)
- Sir Stephen Houghton CBE (Labour)
- Steve Green (Labour)
- Tim Cheetham (Labour)
- Tim Shepherd (Labour)
- Trevor Cave (Labour)
- John Wilson (Conservative)
- Paul Hand-Davis (Conservative)
- Robert Barnard (Conservative)
- Charlesworth (not matched to a member)
- D Birkinshaw (not matched to a member)
- Daniel Griffin (not matched to a member)
- David Griffin (not matched to a member)
- Saunders (not matched to a member)
- W Johnson (not matched to a member)
From the minutes
the Vote, the Motion was lost. In accordance with Standing Order No 18(b) at the request of Councillor P Birkinshaw, supported by more than 10 other Members, a recorded vote was taken on this Motion. In favour of the Motion: Councillors P Birkinshaw, Carr, Felton, Fielding, Gillis, Greenhough, Hunt, Kitching, Lodge and Smith. Against the Motion: The Mayor, Councillor Markham, and Councillors Barnard, D Birkinshaw, Bowler, Bruff, A Cave, T Cave, Charlesworth, Cheetham, Cherryholme, Eastwood, Ennis OBE, Franklin, Frost, Green, Daniel Griffin, David Griffin, Hand-Davis, Hayward, Higginbottom, Sir Steve Houghton CBE, Howard, W Johnson, Lamb, Leech, Lofts, Makinson, McCarthy, Murray, Newing, Pickering, Platts, Saunders, Shepherd, Spence, Stowe, Sumner, Tattersall, Williams, Wilson, Wraith MBE and Wright. There were no abstentions All Members present at the time of the vote actually voted.
The item in the council's own minutes. Names are matched to the councillors listed at the meeting. The names of people who aren't councillors are removed.