Declaration of Interests
Full council, 12 February 2020: a named vote, lost.
For 16, Against 49, Abstained 0.
Party in overall control of the council on the date: No overall control. Each councillor's party is the one the council recorded for them at the time.
For (16)
- Alison Munro (Liberal Democrats)
- Andrew Marchington (Liberal Democrats)
- Andrew Pinnock (Liberal Democrats)
- Anthony Smith (Liberal Democrats)
- Cahal Burke (Liberal Democrats)
- Christine Iredale (Liberal Democrats)
- John Lawson (Liberal Democrats)
- Kath Pinnock (Liberal Democrats)
- Paola Davies (Liberal Democrats)
- Richard Eastwood (Liberal Democrats)
- Andrew Cooper (Green)
- Karen Allison (Green)
- Susan Lee-Richards (Green)
- Charles Greaves (Independent)
- Paul White (Independent)
- Terry Lyons (Independent)
Against (49)
- Aafaq Butt (Labour)
- Amanda Pinnock (Labour)
- Carole Pattison (Labour)
- Cathy Scott (Labour)
- Darren O'Donovan (Labour)
- Eric Firth (Labour)
- Erin Hill (Labour)
- Fazila Loonat (Labour)
- Graham Turner (Labour)
- Gulfam Asif (Labour)
- Gwen Lowe (Labour)
- Habiban Zaman (Labour)
- Harpreet Uppal (Labour)
- Lesley Warner (Labour)
- Manisha Roma Kaushik (Labour)
- Masood Ahmed (Labour)
- Mohammad Sarwar (Labour)
- Mohan Sokhal (Labour)
- Mumtaz Hussain (Labour)
- Musarrat Khan (Labour)
- Mussarat Pervaiz (Labour)
- Naheed Mather (Labour)
- Nosheen Dad (Labour)
- Paul Davies (Labour)
- Peter McBride (Labour)
- Richard Murgatroyd (Labour)
- Shabir Pandor (Labour)
- Sheikh Ullah (Labour)
- Steve Hall (Labour)
- Viv Kendrick (Labour)
- Will Simpson (Labour)
- Yusra Hussain (Labour)
- Bernard McGuin (Conservative)
- Bill Armer (Conservative)
- Charlotte Goodwin (Conservative)
- David Hall (Conservative)
- Donald Firth (Conservative)
- Donna Bellamy (Conservative)
- Elizabeth Smaje (Conservative)
- Kath Taylor (Conservative)
- Lisa Holmes (Conservative)
- Mark Thompson (Conservative)
- Michael Watson (Conservative)
- Michelle Grainger-Mead (Conservative)
- Nigel Patrick (Conservative)
- Richard Smith (Conservative)
- Vivien Lees-Hamilton (Conservative)
- Rob Walker (No party recorded)
- Aleks Lukic (not matched to a member)
From the minutes
on being put to the vote was LOST. In accordance with the requirements of Council Procedure Rule 19 (7), the decision was taken by Recorded Vote as follows; FOR: Councillors Karen Allison, Cahal Burke, Andrew Cooper, Paola Antonia Davies, Richard Eastwood, Charles Greaves, Christine Iredale, John Lawson, Susan Lee-Richards, Terry Lyons, Andrew Marchington, Alison Munro, Andrew Pinnock, Kath Pinnock, Anthony Smith and Paul White (16 votes) AGAINST: Councillors Masood Ahmed, Bill Armer, Gulfam Asif, Donna Bellamy, Aafaq Butt, Nosheen Dad, Paul Davies, Donald Firth, Eric Firth, Charlotte Goodwin, Michelle Grainger-Mead, David Hall, Steve Hall, Erin Hill, Lisa Holmes, James 7 Council – 12 February 2020 Homewood, Mayor (Mumtaz Hussain), Yusra Hussain, Manisha Kaushik, Viv Kendrick, Musarrat Khan, Vivien Lees-Hamilton, Fazila Loonat, Gwen Lowe, Aleks Lukic, Naheed Mather, Peter McBride, Bernard McGuin, Richard Murgatroyd, Darren O'Donovan, Shabir Pandor, Nigel Patrick, Carole Pattison, Mussarat Pervaiz, Amanda Pinnock, Mohammad Sarwar, Cathy Scott, Will Simpson, Elizabeth Smaje, Richard Smith, Mohan Sokhal, Kath Taylor, Mark Thompson, Graham Turner, Sheikh Ullah, Harpreet Uppal, Rob Walker, Lesley Warner, Michael Watson and Habiban Zaman. (50 votes) The Liberal Democrat Amendment, as proposed by Councillor Lawson and seconded by Councillor Marchington, on being put to the vote was LOS
The item in the council's own minutes. Names are matched to the councillors listed at the meeting. The names of people who aren't councillors are removed.