Notice of Motion - Fairness for Garden Waste Users
Full council, 5 November 2025: a named vote, lost.
For 21, Against 31, Abstained 1.
Party in overall control of the council on the date: Labour. Each councillor's party is the one the council recorded for them at the time.
For (21)
- Adam Tinsley BEM (Conservative)
- David Fisher (Conservative)
- Greg Reynolds (Conservative)
- John Blackham (Conservative)
- Joshua Bacon (Conservative)
- Lynda Stables (Conservative)
- Paul Thorp (Conservative)
- Simon Ball (Conservative)
- Sophie Castledine-Dack (Conservative)
- Tim Baum-Dixon (Conservative)
- Tom Collingham (Conservative)
- Zachary Collingham (Conservative)
- Ashiq Hussain (Independent)
- Michael Bennett-Sylvester (Independent)
- Mick Bower (Independent)
- Rob Elliott (Independent)
- Taiba Yasseen (Independent)
- Adam Carter (Liberal Democrats)
- Charlotte Carter (Liberal Democrats)
- Drew Tarmey (Liberal Democrats)
- Tony Harrison (Reform UK)
Against (31)
- Amanda Clarke (Labour)
- Angham Ahmed (Labour)
- Brian Steele (Labour)
- Cameron McKiernan (Labour)
- Chris Read (Labour)
- Dave Jackson (Labour)
- Denise Lelliott (Labour)
- Donna Sutton (Labour)
- Eve Rose Keenan (Labour)
- Gillian Garnett (Labour)
- Gina Monk (Labour)
- James Mault (Labour)
- Jamie Baggaley (Labour)
- Joanna Baker-Rogers (Labour)
- John Williams (Labour)
- Linda Beresford (Labour)
- Liz Duncan (Labour)
- Nigel Harper (Labour)
- Rachel Hughes (Labour)
- Rajmund Brent (Labour)
- Robert Taylor (Labour)
- Rukhsana Ismail (Labour)
- Saghir Alam OBE (Labour)
- Sarah Ann Allen (Labour)
- Sheila Cowen (Labour)
- Terry Adair (Labour)
- Victoria Cusworth (Labour)
- of Rotherham (Councillor Haroon Rashid) (Labour)
- Dave Sheppard (Independent)
- Dominic Beck (Independent)
- Ian Jones (Independent)
Abstained (1)
- Simon Currie (Independent)
From the minutes
cillor Ball had requested that a recorded vote should be taken on the proposed motion. Five Members stood to show their support for a recorded vote to be taken on the motion. The vote was as follows: For (21): Councillors Bacon, Ball, Baum-Dixon, Bennett-Sylvester, Blackham, Bower, A. Carter, C. Carter, Castledine-Dack, T. Collingham, Z. Collingham, Elliott, Fisher, Harrison, Hussain, Reynolds, Stables, Tarmey, Thorp, Tinsley and Yasseen. Against (31): Councillor Adair, Ahmed, Alam, Allen, Baggaley, Baker-Rogers, Beck, Beresford, Brent, Clarke, Cowen, Cusworth, Duncan, Garnett, Harper, Hughes, Ismail, Jackson, Jones, Keenan, Lelliott, Mault, McKiernan, Monk, Rashid, Read, Sheppard, Steele, Sutton, Taylor and Williams. Abstentions (1): Councillor Currie.
The item in the council's own minutes. Names are matched to the councillors listed at the meeting. The names of people who aren't councillors are removed.