Motions on Notice
Full council, 3 September 2025: a named vote, lost.
For 21, Against 38, Abstained 0.
Party in overall control of the council on the date: Reform UK. Each councillor's party is the one the council recorded for them at the time.
For (21)
- Barbara Jenney (Conservative)
- David Howes (Conservative)
- Harry David Howes (Conservative)
- Helen Harrison (Conservative)
- Helen Howell (Conservative)
- Jennie Bone (Conservative)
- Jon Humberstone (Conservative)
- Scott Brown (Conservative)
- Vicki Jessop (Conservative)
- Ben Jameson (Green)
- Ben Williams (Green)
- Dez Dell (Green)
- Emily Fedorowycz (Green)
- James Towns (Green)
- Liane Robinson (Green)
- Polly Shackleton (Green)
- Steve Geary (Green)
- David Baker (Labour)
- Kelly Duddridge (Labour)
- Mark Pengelly (Labour)
- Bill McElhinney (Independent)
Against (38)
- Andy Sims (Reform UK)
- Ash Hall (Reform UK)
- Barry O'Brien (Reform UK)
- Brendon Lovell-Moore (Reform UK)
- Brian Benneyworth (Reform UK)
- Chris Kellett (Reform UK)
- Chris McGiffen (Reform UK)
- Chris Munday (Reform UK)
- Darren Rance (Reform UK)
- David Donnelly (Reform UK)
- Denis McLean (Reform UK)
- Eddie McDonald (Reform UK)
- Elizabeth Wright (Reform UK)
- Gavin Beales (Reform UK)
- Gordon Dunsmuir (Reform UK)
- Graham Cheatley (Reform UK)
- Gregory Wilcox (Reform UK)
- Jan O'Hara (Reform UK)
- Jonathan Carvetta (Reform UK)
- Julie Howe (Reform UK)
- Julie Lumsden (Reform UK)
- Keith Clarke (Reform UK)
- Ken Harrington (Reform UK)
- Kirk Harrison (Reform UK)
- Leon Gibbs (Reform UK)
- Mark Haddon (Reform UK)
- Martin Griffiths (Reform UK)
- Matt Davies (Reform UK)
- Maurice Eglin (Reform UK)
- Paul Brooke (Reform UK)
- Steve Clark (Reform UK)
- Trevor Conway (Reform UK)
- Vinnie Whitrow (Reform UK)
- Vlaho Radin (Reform UK)
- Jim Hakewill (Independent)
- Joseph Garner (Independent)
- Jack Goncalvez (not matched to a member)
- John Lumsden (not matched to a member)
From the minutes
to the vote commencing, a sufficient number of councillors rose in accordance with meeting procedure rule 21.3 to require a recorded vote to be taken. The motion was voted on and recorded as follows: In favour (21 votes) Councillors: David Baker, Scott Brown, Jennie Bone, Dez Dell, Kelly Duddridge, Emily Fedorowycz, Steve Geary, Helen Harrison, Helen Howell, David Howes, Harry Howes, Jon Humberstone, Ben Jameson, Barbara Jenney, Vicki Jessop, Bill McElhinney, Mark Pengelly, Liane Robinson, Polly Shackleton, James Towns, Ben Williams. Abstentions (0 votes) Against (38 votes) Councillors: Gavin Beales, Brian Benneyworth, Paul Brooke, Jonathan Carvetta, Graham Cheatley, Steve Clark, Keith Clarke, Trevor Conway, Matt Davies, David Donnelly, Gordon Dunsmuir, Maurice Eglin, Joe Garner, Leon Gibbs, Martin Griffiths, Jack Goncalvez, Mark Haddon, Jim Hakewill, Ash Hall, Ken Harrington, Kirk Harrison, Julie Howe, Chris Kellett, Brendon Lovell-Moore, John Lumsden, Julie Lumsden, Eddie McDonald, Denis McLean, Chris McGiffen, Chris Munday, Barry O'Brien, Jan O'Hara, Vlaho Radin, Darren Rance, Andy Sims, Vinnie Whitrow, Gregory Wilcox, Elizabeth Wright. Resolved:- That the motion be rejected.
The item in the council's own minutes. Names are matched to the councillors listed at the meeting. The names of people who aren't councillors are removed.