Report of the Independent Remuneration Panel
Full council, 19 January 2021: a named vote on the motion, lost.
For 33, Against 76, Abstained 3.
Party in overall control of the council on the date: No overall control. Each councillor's party is the one the council recorded for them at the time.
For (33)
- Colin Martin (Liberal Democrats)
- David Ekinsmyth (Liberal Democrats)
- Dominic Fairman (Liberal Democrats)
- Hilary Frank (Liberal Democrats)
- Jacquie Gammon (Liberal Democrats)
- Joyce Duffin (Liberal Democrats)
- Leigh Frost (Liberal Democrats)
- Martin Eddy (Liberal Democrats)
- Mathew McCarthy (Liberal Democrats)
- Pete Mitchell (Liberal Democrats)
- Peter La Broy (Liberal Democrats)
- Sue James (Liberal Democrats)
- Bert Biscoe (Independent)
- David Saunby (Independent)
- Graham Coad (Independent)
- John Pollard (Independent)
- John Symons (Independent)
- Julian German (Independent)
- Julian Rand MBE (Independent)
- Mary May (Independent)
- Mike Thomas (Independent)
- Sally Hawken (Independent)
- Tim Dwelly (Independent)
- Andrew Long (Mebyon Kernow - The Party for Cornwall)
- Dick Cole (Mebyon Kernow - The Party for Cornwall)
- Loveday Jenkin (Mebyon Kernow - The Party for Cornwall)
- Matthew Luke (Mebyon Kernow - The Party for Cornwall)
- Cornelius Olivier (Labour)
- Jayne Kirkham (Labour)
- Stephen Barnes (Labour)
- Bob Egerton (IAG)
- Dulcie Tudor (IAG)
- Wallis Those (not matched to a member)
Against (76)
- Adrian Harvey (Conservative)
- Andy Virr (Conservative)
- Barbara Ellenbroek (Conservative)
- Barry Jordan (Conservative)
- Carol Mould (Conservative)
- Colonel Richard Robinson MBE (Conservative)
- David Atherfold (Conservative)
- David Biggs (Conservative)
- David Harris (Conservative)
- Gary Davis (Conservative)
- Geoffrey Evans (Conservative)
- James Mustoe (Conservative)
- Jane Pascoe (Conservative)
- Jim Flashman (Conservative)
- John Bastin (Conservative)
- John Dyer (Conservative)
- John Herd (Conservative)
- John Keeling MBE (Conservative)
- Jordan Rowse (Conservative)
- Kevin Towill (Conservative)
- Mark Formosa (Conservative)
- Martyn Alvey (Conservative)
- Mike McLening (Conservative)
- Oliver Monk (Conservative)
- Pauline Giles (Conservative)
- Peter Williams (Conservative)
- Phil Seeva (Conservative)
- Philip Desmonde (Conservative)
- Richard Pugh (Conservative)
- Richard Williams-Pears (Conservative)
- Roger Harding (Conservative)
- Sally-Anne Saunders (Conservative)
- Sharon Daw (Conservative)
- Sheila Lennox-Boyd (Conservative)
- Simon Elliott (Conservative)
- Stephen Rushworth (Conservative)
- Sue Nicholas (Conservative)
- Tom French (Conservative)
- Adam Paynter (Liberal Democrats)
- Adrian Parsons (Liberal Democrats)
- Andrew Mitchell (Liberal Democrats)
- Chris Batters (Liberal Democrats)
- David Parsons (Liberal Democrats)
- Gemma Massey (Liberal Democrats)
- Geoff Brown (Liberal Democrats)
- Jackie Bull (Liberal Democrats)
- Jesse Foot (Liberal Democrats)
- Joanna Kenny (Liberal Democrats)
- John Martin (Liberal Democrats)
- Malcolm Brown (Liberal Democrats)
- Nicky Chopak (Liberal Democrats)
- Pat Rogerson (Liberal Democrats)
- Richard Buscombe (Liberal Democrats)
- Rob Nolan (Liberal Democrats)
- Rob Rotchell (Liberal Democrats)
- Steve Knightley (Liberal Democrats)
- Armand Toms (Independent)
- Carolyn Rule (Independent)
- Derek Holley (Independent)
- Fred Greenslade (Independent)
- Ian Thomas (Independent)
- Jim McKenna (Independent)
- John Fitter (Independent)
- John Thomas MBE (Independent)
- John Wood (Independent)
- Loic Rich (Independent)
- Mark Kaczmarek (Independent)
- Mike Eathorne-Gibbons (Independent)
- Neil Burden (Independent)
- Paul Wills (Independent)
- Robin Moorcroft (Independent)
- Sandra Heyward (Independent)
- Alan Jewell (not matched to a member)
- Jeff Collins (not matched to a member)
- Linda Taylor (not matched to a member)
- Lionel Pascoe (not matched to a member)
Abstained (3)
- Helen Hawkins (Liberal Democrats)
- Mario Fonk (Liberal Democrats)
- Paula Dolphin (not matched to a member)
From the minutes
Members present requested that a recorded vote be taken for the original proposal. On a vote the original proposal from Councillors Frank and May was lost (33 for, 76 against and 3 abstentions) Those Members voting for the motion:- Councillors Barnes, Biscoe, Coad, Cole, Duffin, Dwelly, Eddy, Egerton, Ekinsmyth, Fairman, Frank, Frost, Gammon, German, Hawken, James, Jenkin, Kirkham, La Broy, Long, Luke, C Martin, May, McCarthy, P Mitchell, Olivier, Pollard, Rand, Saunby, Symons, M Thomas, Tudor and Wallis Those Members voting against the motion:- Councillors Alvey, Atherfold, Bastin, Batters, Biggs, G Brown, M Brown, Bull, Burden, Buscombe, Chopak, Collins, Davis, Daw, Desmonde, Dyer, Eathorne-Gibbons, Ellenbroek, Elliott, Evans, Fitter, Flashman, Foot, Formosa, French, Giles, Greenslade, Harding, Harris, Harvey, Herd, Heyward, Holley, Jewell, Jordan, Kaczmarek, Keeling, Kenny, Knightley, Lennox-Boyd, J Martin, Massey, McKenna, McLening, A Mitchell, Monk, Moorcroft, Mould, Mustoe, Nicholas, Nolan, A Parsons, D Parsons, J Pascoe, L Pascoe, Paynter, Pears, Pugh, Rich, Robinson, Rogerson, Rotchell, Rowse, Rule, Rushworth, Saunders, Seeva, Taylor, I Thomas, J Thomas, Toms, Towill, Virr, P Williams, Wills and Wood. The following Members abstained from voting:- Councillors Dolphin, Fonk and Hawkins. The Chairman clarified that the Council was legally required to have a Scheme of Allowances. It was therefore moved by Councillor Frank, seconded by
The item in the council's own minutes. Names are matched to the councillors listed at the meeting. The names of people who aren't councillors are removed.