Report of the Independent Remuneration Panel
Full council, 19 January 2021: a named vote on the motion, lost.
For 3, Against 94, Abstained 11.
Party in overall control of the council on the date: No overall control. Each councillor's party is the one the council recorded for them at the time.
For (3)
- Colin Martin (Liberal Democrats)
- Mathew McCarthy (Liberal Democrats)
- Dulcie Tudor (IAG)
Against (94)
- Adrian Harvey (Conservative)
- Andy Virr (Conservative)
- Barbara Ellenbroek (Conservative)
- Barry Jordan (Conservative)
- Carol Mould (Conservative)
- Colonel Richard Robinson MBE (Conservative)
- David Atherfold (Conservative)
- David Biggs (Conservative)
- David Harris (Conservative)
- Gary Davis (Conservative)
- Geoffrey Evans (Conservative)
- James Mustoe (Conservative)
- Jane Pascoe (Conservative)
- John Bastin (Conservative)
- John Dyer (Conservative)
- John Herd (Conservative)
- John Keeling MBE (Conservative)
- Jordan Rowse (Conservative)
- Kevin Towill (Conservative)
- Mark Formosa (Conservative)
- Martyn Alvey (Conservative)
- Mike McLening (Conservative)
- Oliver Monk (Conservative)
- Pauline Giles (Conservative)
- Peter Williams (Conservative)
- Phil Seeva (Conservative)
- Philip Desmonde (Conservative)
- Richard Pugh (Conservative)
- Richard Williams-Pears (Conservative)
- Roger Harding (Conservative)
- Sally-Anne Saunders (Conservative)
- Sharon Daw (Conservative)
- Sheila Lennox-Boyd (Conservative)
- Simon Elliott (Conservative)
- Stephen Rushworth (Conservative)
- Sue Nicholas (Conservative)
- Tom French (Conservative)
- Adam Paynter (Liberal Democrats)
- Adrian Parsons (Liberal Democrats)
- Andrew Mitchell (Liberal Democrats)
- Chris Batters (Liberal Democrats)
- David Ekinsmyth (Liberal Democrats)
- David Parsons (Liberal Democrats)
- Dominic Fairman (Liberal Democrats)
- Gemma Massey (Liberal Democrats)
- Geoff Brown (Liberal Democrats)
- Helen Hawkins (Liberal Democrats)
- Hilary Frank (Liberal Democrats)
- Jackie Bull (Liberal Democrats)
- Jacquie Gammon (Liberal Democrats)
- Jesse Foot (Liberal Democrats)
- Joanna Kenny (Liberal Democrats)
- John Martin (Liberal Democrats)
- Joyce Duffin (Liberal Democrats)
- Malcolm Brown (Liberal Democrats)
- Martin Eddy (Liberal Democrats)
- Nicky Chopak (Liberal Democrats)
- Pat Rogerson (Liberal Democrats)
- Peter La Broy (Liberal Democrats)
- Richard Buscombe (Liberal Democrats)
- Rob Nolan (Liberal Democrats)
- Rob Rotchell (Liberal Democrats)
- Steve Knightley (Liberal Democrats)
- Sue James (Liberal Democrats)
- Armand Toms (Independent)
- Carolyn Rule (Independent)
- David Saunby (Independent)
- Derek Holley (Independent)
- Fred Greenslade (Independent)
- Ian Thomas (Independent)
- Jim McKenna (Independent)
- John Fitter (Independent)
- John Pollard (Independent)
- John Symons (Independent)
- John Thomas MBE (Independent)
- John Wood (Independent)
- Julian German (Independent)
- Julian Rand MBE (Independent)
- Loic Rich (Independent)
- Mary May (Independent)
- Mike Eathorne-Gibbons (Independent)
- Paul Wills (Independent)
- Robin Moorcroft (Independent)
- Sally Hawken (Independent)
- Sandra Heyward (Independent)
- Andrew Long (Mebyon Kernow - The Party for Cornwall)
- Dick Cole (Mebyon Kernow - The Party for Cornwall)
- Loveday Jenkin (Mebyon Kernow - The Party for Cornwall)
- Matthew Luke (Mebyon Kernow - The Party for Cornwall)
- Bob Egerton (IAG)
- Alan Jewell (not matched to a member)
- Jeff Collins (not matched to a member)
- Linda Taylor (not matched to a member)
- Lionel Pascoe (not matched to a member)
Abstained (11)
- Bert Biscoe (Independent)
- Graham Coad (Independent)
- Mike Thomas (Independent)
- Tim Dwelly (Independent)
- Cornelius Olivier (Labour)
- Jayne Kirkham (Labour)
- Stephen Barnes (Labour)
- Leigh Frost (Liberal Democrats)
- Pete Mitchell (Liberal Democrats)
- Andrew Wallis (IAG)
- Paula Dolphin (not matched to a member)
From the minutes
ocedure Rule 16.4 (b) more than a third of those Members present requested that a recorded vote be taken for the proposal. On a vote the proposal was lost (3 for, 94 against and 11 abstentions) Those Members voting for the motion:- Councillors C Martin, McCarthy and Tudor. Those Members voting against the motion:- Councillors Alvey, Atherfold, Bastin, Batters, Biggs, G Brown, M Brown, Bull, Buscombe, Chopak, Cole, Collins, Davis, Daw, Desmonde, Duffin, Dyer, Eathorne-Gibbons, Eddy, Egerton, Ekinsmyth, Ellenbroek, Elliott, Evans, Fairman, Fitter, Foot, Formosa, Frank, French, Gammon, German, Giles, Greenslade, Harding, Harris, Harvey, Hawken, Hawkins, Herd, Heyward, Holley, James, Jenkin, Jewell, Jordan, Keeling, Kenny, Knightley, La Broy, Lennox-Boyd, Long, Luke, J Martin, Massey, May, McKenna, McLening, A Mitchell, Monk, Moorcroft, Mould, Mustoe, Nicholas, Nolan, A Parsons, D Parsons, J Pascoe, L Pascoe, Paynter, Pears, Pollard, Pugh, Rand, Rich, Robinson, Rogerson, Rotchell, Rowse, Rule, Rushworth, Saunby, Saunders, Seeva, Symons, Taylor, I Thomas, J Thomas, Toms, Towill, Virr, P Williams, Wills and Wood. The following Members abstained from voting:- Councillors Barnes, Biscoe, Coad, Dolphin, Dwelly, Frost, Kirkham, P Mitchell, Olivier, M Thomas and Wallis. It was proposed as a further amendment by Councillor Wills, seconded by Councillor McKenna that: (i) The Panel's recommendations be deferred until t
The item in the council's own minutes. Names are matched to the councillors listed at the meeting. The names of people who aren't councillors are removed.