Notice of Motion: Renewed call for Councillors to reintroduce respectful debate and review all decisions impacted by ideology rather than hard evidence
Full council, 16 May 2024: a named vote on the motion, lost.
For 28, Against 39, Abstained 0.
Party in overall control of the council on the date: Labour. Each councillor's party is the one the council recorded for them at the time.
For (28)
- Adrian Waddelove (Conservative)
- Charles Hardy (Conservative)
- Dan Marr (Conservative)
- Gaynor Sinar (Conservative)
- Graham Heatley (Conservative)
- Hugo Deynem (Conservative)
- Lynn Gibbon (Conservative)
- Lynn Stocks (Conservative)
- Margaret Parker (Conservative)
- Mark Stocks (Conservative)
- Mark Williams (Conservative)
- Martin Loftus (Conservative)
- Myles Hogg (Conservative)
- Patricia Parkes (Conservative)
- Phil Marshall (Conservative)
- Phil Rimmer (Conservative)
- Rachel Williams (Conservative)
- Razia Daniels (Conservative)
- Simon Eardley (Conservative)
- Stuart Parker MBE (Conservative)
- Tom Cooper (Conservative)
- Gill Watson (Non-aligned Independent)
- Martin Beveridge (Non-aligned Independent)
- Simon Boone (Non-aligned Independent)
- Gillian Edwards (Independent)
- Martin Barker (Independent)
- Ted Lush (Liberal Democrats)
- Mandy Clare (not matched to a member)
Against (39)
- Adam Langan (Labour)
- Alan Smith (Labour)
- Alex Tate (Labour)
- Andrew Cooper (Labour)
- Arthur Neil (Labour)
- Ben Walker (Labour)
- Carol Gahan (Labour)
- Caroline Ellis (Labour)
- Christine Warner (Labour)
- Elizabeth MacGlashan (Labour)
- Felicity Davies (Labour)
- Gareth Gould (Labour)
- Gina Lewis (Labour)
- Jimmy Shannon (Labour)
- John Stockton (Labour)
- Karen Shore (Labour)
- Katie Kendrick OBE (Labour)
- Katrina Kerr (Labour)
- Lisa Denson (Labour)
- Louise Gittins (Labour)
- Lucy Sumner (Labour)
- Matt Carter (Labour)
- Michael Garvey (Labour)
- Nathan Pardoe (Labour)
- Olwyn Dean (Labour)
- Paul Chamberlain (Labour)
- Paul Donovan (Labour)
- Peter Wheeler OBE (Labour)
- Richard Beacham (Labour)
- Robert Bisset (Labour)
- Sam Naylor (Labour)
- Sheila Little (Labour)
- Sherin Akhtar (Labour)
- Steve Collings (Labour)
- Stuart Bingham (Labour)
- Tommy Blackmore (Labour)
- Chris Copeman (not matched to a member)
- John Roach (not matched to a member)
- Keith Miller (not matched to a member)
From the minutes
he rights of all should be upheld. Councillor Many Clare requested a named vote in accordance with Procedure Rule Part 3 paragraph 117, more than 8 Councillors rose to request a named, recorded vote. For the Motion (28) Councillor Martin Barker, Martin Beveridge, Simon Boone, Mandy Clare, Tom Cooper, Razia Daniels, Hugo Deynem, Simon Eardley, Gillian Edwards, Lynn Gibbon, Charles Hardy, Graham Heatley, Myles Hogg, Martin Loftus, Ted Lush, Dan Marr, Phil Marshall, Margaret Parker, Stuart Parker MBE, Patricia Parkes, Phil Rimmer, Gaynor Sinar, Lynn Stocks, Mark Stocks, Adrian Waddelove, Gill Watson, Mark Williams, Rachel Williams. Against the motion (39) Councillor Robert Bisset, Sherin Akhtar, Richard Beacham, Stuart Bingham, Tommy Blackmore, Matt Carter, Paul Chamberlain, Steve Collings, Andrew Cooper, Chris Copeman, Felicity Davies, Olwyn Dean, Lisa Denson, Paul Donovan, Caroline Ellis, Carol Gahan, Mike Garvey, Louise Gittins, Gareth Gould, Katie Kendrick, Katrina Kerr, Adam Langan, Gina Lewis, Sheila Little, Elizabeth MacGlashan, Keith Miller, Sam Naylor, Arthur Neil, Nathan Pardoe, John Roach, Jimmy Shannon, Karen Shore, Alan Smith, John Stockton, Lucy Sumner, Alex Tate, Ben Walker, Christine Warner, Peter Wheeler. Abstentions (0) The Motion was put to the vote and was lost.
The item in the council's own minutes. Names are matched to the councillors listed at the meeting. The names of people who aren't councillors are removed.