Call-in of Executive decision made on 14 June 2023 - Home to School Transport Services - Consultation Outcomes - Report of Corporate Director of Resources
Full council, 19 July 2023: a named vote on the motion, lost.
For 52, Against 53, Abstained 0.
Party in overall control of the council on the date: No overall control. Each councillor's party is the one the council recorded for them at the time.
For (52)
- Alison Batey (Labour)
- Angela Hanson (Labour)
- Angela Surtees (Labour)
- Carl Marshall (Labour)
- Carole Hampson (Labour)
- Charlie Kay (Labour)
- Christine Fletcher (Labour)
- Curtis Bihari (Labour)
- Dan Nicholls (Labour)
- Danny Wood (Labour)
- David Boyes (Labour)
- David Hall (Labour)
- David McKenna (Labour)
- Eddy Adam (Labour)
- Fraser Tinsley (Labour)
- George Smith (Labour)
- Ian McLean (Labour)
- Isabella Roberts (Labour)
- Jake Miller (Labour)
- Jean Chaplow (Labour)
- Jim Atkinson (Labour)
- John Higgins (Labour)
- John Purvis (Labour)
- Julie Griffiths (Labour)
- Julie Scurfield (Labour)
- Karan Batey (Labour)
- Kevin Earley (Labour)
- Kevin Shaw (Labour)
- Louise Fenwick (Labour)
- Lucy Hovvels (Labour)
- Marion Wilson (Labour)
- Matt Johnson (Labour)
- Maura McKeon (Labour)
- Olwyn Gunn (Labour)
- Paul Pringle (Labour)
- Peter Atkinson (Labour)
- Richard Manchester (Labour)
- Rob Crute (Labour)
- Rob Yorke (Labour)
- Robert Adcock-Forster (Labour)
- Sam McMahon (Labour)
- Samantha Townsend (Labour)
- Shirley Quinn (Labour)
- Simon Henig (Labour)
- Simon Wilson (Labour)
- Stacey Deinali (Labour)
- Tracie Smith (Labour)
- Veronica Andrews (Labour)
- Billy McAloon (Independent)
- Diane Howarth (Independent)
- Karen Hawley (Independent)
- Liz Maddison (Independent)
Against (53)
- Andrew Jackson (Conservative)
- Angela Sterling (Conservative)
- David Brown (Conservative)
- David Sutton-Lloyd (Conservative)
- Douglas Oliver (Conservative)
- Elaine Peeke (Conservative)
- George Richardson (Conservative)
- James Cosslett (Conservative)
- James Rowlandson (Conservative)
- Joanne Howey (Conservative)
- Joe Quinn (Conservative)
- Michelle Walton (Conservative)
- Mike Currah (Conservative)
- Mike McGaun (Conservative)
- Patricia Jopling (Conservative)
- Richard Bell (Conservative)
- Robert Potts (Conservative)
- Ted Henderson (Conservative)
- Tony Stubbs (Conservative)
- Amanda Hopgood (Liberal Democrats)
- Arnie Simpson (Liberal Democrats)
- Bev Coult (Liberal Democrats)
- Craig Martin (Liberal Democrats)
- David Freeman (Liberal Democrats)
- David Stoker (Liberal Democrats)
- Dominic Haney (Liberal Democrats)
- Elizabeth Scott (Liberal Democrats)
- Eric Mavin (Liberal Democrats)
- Kathryn Rooney (Liberal Democrats)
- Lesley Mavin (Liberal Democrats)
- Liz Brown (Liberal Democrats)
- Mamie Simmons (Liberal Democrats)
- Mark Wilkes (Liberal Democrats)
- Neville Jones (Liberal Democrats)
- Richard Ormerod (Liberal Democrats)
- Anita Savory (Independent)
- Anne Reed (Independent)
- Chris Hood (Independent)
- Chris Lines (Independent)
- Gary Hutchinson (Independent)
- Jan Blakey (Independent)
- John Shuttleworth (Independent)
- Ken Robson (Independent)
- Pete Molloy (Independent)
- Phil Heaviside (Independent)
- Sam Zair (Independent)
- Watts Stelling (Independent)
- Alan Shield (Derwentside Independents)
- Joan Nicholson (Derwentside Independents)
- Stephen Robinson (Derwentside Independents)
- Susan McDonnell (The Party Party)
- Terry Duffy (The Party Party)
- Jonathan Elmer (Green)
From the minutes
in consultation with the s151 officer and the monitoring officer and was a valid referral. COSMB had a duty to hold Cabinet to account in line with the Council's Constitution. Upon a vote being taken For the Motion Councillors E Adam, R Adcock-Forster, V Andrews, J Atkinson, P Atkinson, A Batey, K Batey, C Bihari, D Boyes, J Chaplow, R Crute, S Deinali, K Earley, L Fenwick, C Fletcher, J Griffiths, O Gunn, D Hall, C Hampson, A Hanson, K Hawley, S Henig, J Higgins, L Hovvels, D Howarth, M Johnson, C Kay, L Maddison, R Manchester, C Marshall, B McAloon, D McKenna, M McKeon, I McLean, S McMahon, J Miller, D Nicholls, P Pringle, J Purvis, S Quinn, I Roberts, J Scurfield, K Shaw, G Smith, T Smith, A Surtees, F Tinsley, S Townsend, M Wilson, S Wilson, D Wood and R Yorke. Against the Motion Councillors R Bell, J Blakey, D Brown, L Brown, J Cosslett, B Coult, M Currah, T Duffy, J Elmer, D Freeman, D Haney, P Heaviside, T Henderson, C Hood, A Hopgood, J Howey, G Hutchinson, A Jackson, N Jones, P Jopling, C Lines, C Martin, E Mavin, L Mavin, S McDonnell, M McGaun, P Molloy, J Nicholson, D Oliver, R Ormerod, E Peeke, R Potts, J Quinn, A Reed, G Richardson, S Robinson, K Robson, K Rooney, J Rowlandson, A Savory, E Scott, A Shield, J Shuttleworth, M Simmons, A Simpson, W Stelling, A Sterling, D Stoker, T Stubbs, D Sutton-Lloyd, M Walton, M Wilkes and S Zair. The Motion was Lost.
The item in the council's own minutes. Names are matched to the councillors listed at the meeting. The names of people who aren't councillors are removed.