Second Report of the LGSCO - Maladministration causing injustice
Full council, 18 September 2025: a named vote on the amendment, lost.
For 17, Against 26, Abstained 0.
Party in overall control of the council on the date: Labour. Each councillor's party is the one the council recorded for them at the time.
For (17)
- Abdul Osman (Conservative)
- Bhupen Dave (Conservative)
- Devi Singh Patel (Conservative)
- Hazel Orton (Conservative)
- Hemant Rae Bhatia (Conservative)
- Jenny Joannou (Conservative)
- Paul Westley (Conservative)
- Ravi Mahesh (Conservative)
- Sanjay Modhwadia (Conservative)
- Shital Adatia (Conservative)
- Yogesh Chauhan (Conservative)
- Liz Sahu (Green)
- Mick Gregg (Green)
- Patrick Kitterick (Green)
- Nigel Porter (Liberal Democrats)
- Scott Kennedy-Lount (Liberal Democrats)
- Zuffar Haq (Liberal Democrats)
Against (26)
- Ashiedu Joel (Labour)
- Deepak Bajaj (Labour)
- Dr Susan Barton (Labour)
- Elaine Halford (Labour)
- Elaine Pantling (Labour)
- Elly Cutkelvin (Labour)
- Geoff Whittle (Labour)
- Karen Pickering (Labour)
- Kulwinder Singh Johal (Labour)
- Manjit Kaur Saini (Labour)
- Manjula Sood (Labour)
- Melissa March (Labour)
- Misbah Batool (Labour)
- Mohammed Dawood (Labour)
- Mohinder Singh Sangha BEM (Labour)
- Molly O'Neill (Labour)
- Mustafa Malik (Labour)
- Raffiq Moosa Mohammed (Labour)
- Sarah Russell (Labour)
- Stephen Bonham (Labour)
- Ted Cassidy MBE (Labour)
- Teresa Aldred (Labour)
- Vi Dempster (Labour)
- Yasmin Surti (Labour)
- Nags Agath (Independent)
- Soulsby (City Mayor) (not matched to a member)
From the minutes
uncil makes the payment to Ms X as soon as possible' Following the debate on the amendment, under Council Procedure Rule 29 of the Council's Constitution, three Councillors requested a recorded vote. For the Amendment (17): Councillors: Adatia, Chauhan, Dave, Gregg, Haq Joannou, Kennedy-Lount, Kitterick, Mahesh, Modhwadia, Orton, Osman, Porter, Rae Bhatia, Sahu, Singh Patel, Westley Against the Amendment (26): Councillors: Agath, Aldred (Lord Mayor), Bajaj, Barton, Batool, Bonham, Cassidy, Cutkelvin, Dawood, Dempster, Halford, Joel, Kaur Saini, Malik, March, Mohammed, O'Neill, Pantling, Pickering, Russell, Singh Johal, Singh Sangha, Sood, Soulsby (City Mayor), Surti and Whittle. The Lord Mayor declared the amendment lost. Following the debate on the original motion a vote was put to the chamber and the Lord Mayor declared th
The item in the council's own minutes. Names are matched to the councillors listed at the meeting. The names of people who aren't councillors are removed.