Minutes
Full council, 22 January 2020: a named vote on the recommendations, lost.
For 19, Against 15, Abstained 14.
Party in overall control of the council on the date: No overall control. Each councillor's party is the one the council recorded for them at the time.
For (19)
- Adrian Pegg (Conservative)
- Alison Holmes (Conservative)
- Christopher Poulter (Conservative)
- Frank Harwood (Conservative)
- Ged Potter (Conservative)
- James Testro (Conservative)
- Jerry Pearce (Conservative)
- Jonathan Smale (Conservative)
- Matthew Holmes (Conservative)
- Mick Barker (Conservative)
- Miles Pattison (Conservative)
- Nicola Roulstone (Conservative)
- Richard Hudson (Conservative)
- Rob Cooper (Conservative)
- Robin Wood (Conservative)
- Ross McCristal (Conservative)
- Roy Webb (Conservative)
- Steve Hassall (Conservative)
- Williams (not matched to a member)
Against (15)
- Ajit Singh Atwal (Liberal Democrats)
- Danielle Lind (Liberal Democrats)
- Eric Ashburner (Liberal Democrats)
- Joe Naitta (Liberal Democrats)
- Lucy Care (Liberal Democrats)
- Mike Carr (Liberal Democrats)
- Ruth Skelton (Liberal Democrats)
- Stephen Willoughby (Liberal Democrats)
- Diane Froggatt (Independent)
- Philip Ingall (Independent)
- Alan J Graves (not matched to a member)
- Alan W Graves (not matched to a member)
- John Evans (not matched to a member)
- Kirk Kus (not matched to a member)
- Paul Bettany (not matched to a member)
Abstained (14)
- Baggy Shanker (Labour)
- Balbir Sandhu (Labour)
- Fareed Hussain (Labour)
- Gulfraz Nawaz (Labour)
- Hardyal Dhindsa (Labour)
- Jack Stanton (Labour)
- Jangir Khan (Labour)
- Joanna West (Labour)
- Lisa Eldret (Labour)
- Martin Repton (Labour)
- Nadine Peatfield (Labour)
- Paul Hezelgrave (Labour)
- Sarah Russell (Labour)
- Shiraz Khan (Labour)
From the minutes
The amendment was lost. As required under Rule CP71a of the Council Procedure Rules, it was demanded by at least 10 members that a recorded vote be taken. The voting was as follows: For the recommendations as printed: Councillors Barker, Cooper, Harwood, Hassall, A Holmes, M Holmes, Hudson, McCristal, Pattison, Pearce, A Pegg, Potter, Poulter, Roulstone, Smale, Testro, Webb, Williams and Wood (19) Against the recommendation as printed: Councillors Atwal, Ashburner, Bettany, Care, Carr, Evans, Froggatt, A W Graves, A J Graves, Ingall, Kus, Lind, Naitta, Skelton and Willoughby (15) Abstentions: Councillors Dhindsa, Eldret, Hezelgrave, Hussain, J Khan, S Khan, Nawaz, Peatfield, Repton, Russell, Sandhu, Shanker, Stanton and West (14) Resolved: 1. To note that it had not been possible to develop a committee system of governance that meets all of the seven working principles. 2. To
The item in the council's own minutes. Names are matched to the councillors listed at the meeting. The names of people who aren't councillors are removed.