Notice of Motion - To consider a Motion submitted by Councillor Harker, and seconded by Councillor Paley
Full council, 5 December 2019: a named vote on the motion, lost.
For 19, Against 25, Abstained 0.
Party in overall control of the council on the date: No overall control. Each councillor's party is the one the council recorded for them at the time.
For (19)
- Andrew Scott (Labour)
- Chris McEwan (Labour)
- Cyndi Hughes (Labour)
- Helen Crumbie (Labour)
- Hilary Lucas (Labour)
- Ian Haszeldine (Labour)
- Jan Cossins (Labour)
- Libby McCollom (Labour)
- Linda Hughes (Labour)
- Lynn Paley (Labour)
- Mary Layton (Labour)
- Michael Nicholson (Labour)
- Nick Wallis (Labour)
- Sam Howarth (Labour)
- Stephen Harker (Labour)
- Wendy Newall (Labour)
- Bryony Holroyd PhD (Green)
- Matthew Snedker (Green)
- Lister (not matched to a member)
Against (25)
- Alan Marshall (Conservative)
- Andy Keir (Conservative)
- Bob Donoghue (Conservative)
- Brian Jones (Conservative)
- Deborah Laing (Conservative)
- Dr Christy Chou (Conservative)
- Gerald Lee (Conservative)
- Jamie Bartch BA, MA (Conservative)
- Jon Clarke (Conservative)
- Jonathan Dulston (Conservative)
- Lisa Preston (Conservative)
- Lorraine Tostevin (Conservative)
- Mike Renton (Conservative)
- Mrs Pauline Culley MBE (Conservative)
- Paul Crudass (Conservative)
- Paul Howell (Conservative)
- Scott Durham (Conservative)
- Darrien Wright (D'tonIND)
- Kevin Nicholson (D'tonIND)
- Steven Tait (D'tonIND)
- Hilary Allen (Liberal Democrats)
- Boddy (not matched to a member)
- Johnson (not matched to a member)
- Mrs. D. Jones (not matched to a member)
- Mrs. H. Scott (not matched to a member)
From the minutes
rdance with Council Procedure Rules, a request was made by five Members for a named vote on the Substantive Motion. A named vote was taken of those Members present at the meeting and there appeared:- For the Motion – The Mayor, Councillors Cossins, Crumbie, Harker, Haszeldine, Holroyd, Howarth, C. L. B. Hughes, L. Hughes, Layton, Lister, Lucas, McCollom, McEwan, Newall, M. Nicholson, Paley, A. J. Scott and Snedker (19) Against the Motion – Councillors Allen, Bartch, Boddy, Dr. Chou, Clarke, Crudass, Mrs. Culley, Donoghue, Dulston, Durham, Howell, Johnson, B. Jones, Mrs. D. Jones, Keir, Laing, Lee, Marshall, K. Nicholson, Preston, Renton, Mrs. H. Scott, Tait, Tostevin and Wright (25) The Motion was Lost.
The item in the council's own minutes. Names are matched to the councillors listed at the meeting. The names of people who aren't councillors are removed.